No Process? No Business.

Influency Marketing on FaceookInfluency Marketing on LinkedInInfluency Marketing on Google+Influency Marketing on Twitter

Be Afraid: Google’s Rules for Search Are About To Change

Time to dredge up that old “Is Google a Monopoly?” issue again.

I don’t like this topic, because as a free-enterprise guy and a keen observer of Google and how they do business I’m mostly inclined to scoff at the idea that Google is a monopoly. The argument usually comes down to whether the definition of monopoly skews toward its literal meaning or one that’s more metaphorical; at 65-70% of search traffic, isn’t “a monopoly” the de facto reality of what Google has become?

Google has announced that they’re planning to change the way their search results work, shifting from what’s always been a fairly literal, brute-force method of indexing the Internet to what’s being called “semantic search”. Semantic search relies on elements of Artificial Intelligence to guess at what you’re asking when you pose a question. It’s kind of like what Apple’s Siri on the iPhone 4S does; and when it works, it’s a better search.

I emphasize the “when it work” part because reliable, adaptive, semantic Artificial Intelligence is still a ways off. I also tell you about this because as a Search Engine Optimization consultant I’m concerned for what this shift means.

Last week, Google’s Matt Cutts let slip that Google is also taking a look at what he’s calling “over optimization”. Again, speaking from the I do Search Engine Optimization perspective, this worries me plenty, along the lines of “geez, how will I adapt to that?”, but it also scares me at a much higher level.

Google and Mr. Cutts have previously and continuously stated that doing SEO is OK as long as you follow Google’s rules for Search Engine Optimization. And in giving you that link and many of the other links here I’m both pointing you at related content and practicing Search Engine Optimization in exactly the way Google’s always said is “correct”.

My concern is that Google isn’t providing a definition for “over optimization”, nor are they saying what the penalty will be if you get caught in the “Google thinks you’re over optimizing” trap. So now, if you write something on your web site and Google thinks you’ve been naughty, you’re … well, you’re screwed.

I’m rethinking my stance that the FTC should leave Google alone.

Matt Cutts has previously revealed a few things that are useful in deconstructing Google’s Secret Sauce. For example, we know that PageRank is Finite. But if they insist on changing the rules of search such that you can be penalized for doing things that A) used to be allowed and B) haven’t actually been defined, Google needs to first come clean about their search ranking algorithms. That revelation will be so dense that almost nobody will be able to really glean anything new from it, anyway—especially if Google holds onto that “because we said so” wild card.

Google’s software is frequently a mess of misdirects; Google+, for example, isn’t really Social Networking at all; it’s social control. And Google has shown some weakness on the Anti-Trust/Monopoly issue before. It’s all pretty complicated, and I suspect is headed toward a showdown of monumental proportions between Google and the US Congress.

Before that happens, I have a simple recommendation: Contact Me about Search Engine Optimization.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. "What People Do Is The New SEO" (Semantic Search) - [...] mentioned the changing face of search and search engine optimization earlier this week. Google is changing the rules for search engine …
  2. Bing REWARDS? Bing Toolbar? Where's the Coopetition? - [...] programs like Bing Rewards. They’ll participate in them. And there’s certainly enough concern building about the way Google does …
  3. At Home Depot, Black-Hat SEO is "The New Hammer" - [...] whether or not Google is willing to specifically admit it. And it will remain true even after Google’s new …
  4. So Now That Siri Has Been With Us for A While . . . - [...] Anecdotally, I can tell you that my iPhone 4S-toting family members gave up on Siri after playing with her for …
  5. Google Owns Everything (The Simplicity of World Domination) - [...] The key is knowing what you can do, and what you’d be better off leaving alone. So sure, you …
  6. Naked Women, Statistics, Search, and Artificial Intelligence - [...] where the words you use in querying the Google Search Engine isn’t what matters. Via the knowledge graph, Google …
  7. Want a link killed? Pay me. How do you spell 'Extortion'? - [...] The issue gets ugly when “pay me to remove this nasty thing I’ve written about you” becomes a form …
  8. Google Chromebook: Not a Phone, But: Computer, or Toy? - [...] as a user, and as long as you’re OK with Google being your everything, computing-wise, this doesn’t [...]
  9. 'It Takes a Village', And Here's that Village, 2012 . . . - [...] the way young people look at older folks. We can even make ‘It takes a village’ about Artificial Intelligence …
  10. Can You Trust Google? — Or Is it WHEN Can You Trust Google? - [...] using a Chromebook was a good one, and I feel the same way about my Nexus 7 tablet. And …
  11. Influency, Google Now, Too Much Information Floating Around - [...] Google’s tweaks are getting better and smarter. I’ve mentioned before that privacy, a relatively new construct, is something you probably shouldn’t …
  12. Those Tiny Google Hummingbirds Do Local Semantic Search - […] is a big deal in the Influency world, especially in Optimization. But in a rare break from the way …
  13. Optimizing 'What Time Is The Super Bowl?' - […] Google decided that the space character doesn’t matter? No. Google’s gotten smarter, and the fact that people sometimes spell the …

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Follow

Get new posts delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers: