Statistics Lie. Are You Listening, Hubspot and Shareaholic?

I’ll bet you have a few things that are always on your mind as you move through your day. Me too. One is something I’ve mentioned before: Statistics Lie.

It’s like the conversation about “Perception is Reality“. Except that in the case of statistics, the goal is to intentionally manipulate the perception that other people have of realities surrounding your stories. Reality doesn’t develop as a result of perception, it’s manipulated.

I thought about this today when I was looking at the statistics provided by Shareaholic about how often readers here send what they find to other places. Shareaholic is the company that helps put all those little icons at the bottom of the posts in Answer Guy Central Changes, and they let me see how often you share our work—and where.

Here’s what Shareaholic says:

  • In the last 30 days, Shareaholic helped share content from Answer Guy Central 61 times
  • That makes us the 676th most-popular site among Shareaholic users
  • There are over 415,000 Shareaholic users
  • The guy who’s most popular has almost 6,000 shares in the same 30 day period that Shareaholic reports us as having 61.

If I wanted to spin these statistics in a positive way, I’d tell you that according to Shareaholic, Answer Guy Central is more influential than 99.8% of all web sites (676 against 415,000). Or better yet, I’d leave out the “according to Shareaholic” part and just quote the statistics as reality: Answer Guy Central is more influential than 99.8% of all web sites. Wow! Look at Me!

Here’s another example of how statistics can be made to lie:

Hubspot reports that our marketing of Answer Guy Central is more effective than 98% of all web sites’ marketing efforts. Hubspot also reports that Answer Guy Central has more traffic than over 96% of all web sites.

Statistics Lie at Hubspot

More Statistics Lie at Hubspot

It all sounds pretty impressive, doesn’t it? I hope so, because Perception is Reality.

But here’s an alternate perception of the same reality: 61 engagements via Shareaholic is pretty lame when you compare it to 6,000 (that guy at the top is 100 times better than we are) and while being in the top 3.84% of all web sites sounds great, the fact that almost 1.2 million sites get more traffic that we do is pretty awful—especially when you consider that the site reporting that statistic to Hubspot doesn’t bother keeping details on any sites outside the first 100,000.

Yikes.

Then, there’s the centrist position: based on the statistics we gather ourselves and those being reported to us by Hubspot and Shareaholic, I’m pleased with the results we see from our marketing efforts. We do this all using long-tail marketing techniques and Search Engine Optimization, using the same successful marketing techniques we apply for our clients.

So am I saying that you should ignore or mistrust what Shareaholic tells you, or what comes out of Hubspot’s tools? No. We use Shareaholic because it gives our readers an option to be social, and we’re planning to keep using Shareaholic. And while we don’t use and generally recommend against Hubspot, we believe that the information they provide has value.

Just remember that statistics lie. And THAT perception is everybody’s reality.